Local Restaurants
SEO Heading Title H1
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.
Our Favorite Mystic Restaurants
There are plenty of great things to do in Mystic, and food is definitely one of them! In fact, for many visitors, food is the reason they’ve come to our endearing riverside town. These travelers won’t be disappointed, either. The food scene here reflects the character of the town itself: coastal, thoughtful, and grounded in quality ingredients.
From chef-driven kitchens to long-standing local favorites, Mystic restaurants offer plenty of satisfying variety. Seafood is, of course, featured on quite a few menus around town, but the culinary range extends well beyond the harbor, with menus shaped by regional farms, global influence, and a dedication to craft that’s unmistakable.
Many of the best restaurants in Mystic are clustered within walking distance of our downtown hotel, allowing guests to enjoy different experiences without planning or driving. We offer award-winning dining on site and walkable ease to most of the other popular places to eat in Mystic. Whether you are planning a food-focused getaway or simply want great meals woven naturally into your stay, we think you’ll love this curated collection of Mystic restaurants.
All within 1/4 mile walking distance of the Inn
Classy, Casual, and Cocktails
The Shipwright’s Daughter – In House Restaurant
Located right here at The Whaler’s Inn in downtown Mystic. A New American tide-to-table restaurant, serving modern New England cuisine in an elegant and inviting dining room, which combines a rustic ode to Mystic’s fishing and maritime roots, with the updated modern feel of an urban bistro.
Open seven days a week, serving breakfast daily and brunch on weekends. Dinner reservations are recommended.
Featuring farm-to-table fare and a menu that changes daily based on what’s fresh and in-season, this Water Street restaurant offers casual fine dining.
Port of Call
Downtown Mystic’s latest addition…cocktail lounge with small plates “inspired by flavors, recipes and ingredients from storied coastal communities from around the globe.”
Below deck from The Port of Call, you’ll find Dive, a watering hole in the belly of the beast, inspired by the bygone days of deep-sea exploration.
Red 36
Overlooking the Mystic River, Red 36 is a hidden “seafood-centric” gem tucked away behind Seaport Marine. Outdoor seating is available.
Engine Room
Located just around the corner from the Inn, The Engine Room offers creative comfort food and an exceptional beer & bourbon selection. Don’t miss their Sunday brunch!
Chapter One Fine Food and Drink
Chapter One specializes in prime dry-aged steaks, fresh fish, and small plates.
Featuring locally sourced ingredients and a cozy, romantic atmosphere, their twists on classic Italian will transport your taste buds to the cobblestone streets of Emilia-Romagna, Italy.
Garden Oasis rooftop cocktail bar serving hand-crafted cocktails, local beers, and a playful food menu above Sift Bakeshop.
Andiamo is a delightful Italian restaurant with delicious dishes and a cozy atmosphere. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or an evening with friends.
Casual Spots for Family & Friends
An Old English Tavern with great food and drink, Friar Tuck’s is a great place to come relax with friends…new and old.
Enjoy “a slice of heaven” at this Main Street pizzeria made famous by the 1980s film starring Julia Roberts.
A charming Irish pub offering a delightful blend of traditional Irish fare and live music.
A specialty Ramen restaurant with indoor and outdoor dining in the heart of downtown.
Experience the unique fusion of traditional Mexican flavors and south-of-the-border zest at Taquerio. Enjoy this once-vintage gas station transformed into a hip taqueria that offers delicious street tacos, tasty nachos, refreshing margaritas, and more!
Local Classics
Captain Daniel Packer
Charming and cozy, this historic Inn features hearty, traditional New England fare. Dine in the restaurant or in the pub and imagine what life was like in 1756!
A.J.’s
An ever-popular bistro, A.J.’s offers traditional Italian fare on nearby Holmes Street.
Located within Olde Mistick Village, Amalfi’s coastal Italian flavors focus on the freshest local seafood, seasonal ingredients, and of course, their famous fresh pasta, always made in-house.